Borders DMG

History of the Group

The Borders Sika Control Group (later renamed the Borders Sika Deer Management Group) was established under the aegis of the Red Deer Commission (RDC) on 25 November 1986. Its first chairman was Ian MacKenzie, who was also RDC chairman.  At this time, the necessity to manage the expanding sika population in the upper Tweed valley had become apparent and was typified by extensive sika bark stripping in commercial conifers and agricultural damage. Total sika cull at that time was 122 sika out of an estimated population of 600.

The initial aims of the BSCG were to contain forest along with agricultural damage and prevent the range expansion of sika and, in particular, prevent sika expansion beyond the M74 – where there was potential for hybridisation with red deer in Galloway – and the A708, the Selkirk to Moffat road.

Tony Waterson, OBE from Ayrshire was appointed as successor to Ian MacKenzie. It had been decided that another ‘out-of-area’ chairman would be seen to be impartial in the debates that were to follow.  Then, as now, reconciling the differing land-use and sporting aspirations of neighbouring landowners provided an early challenge.

In the late 1990’s research was undertaken by St Andrew University and the, renamed, Deer Commission to model the sika population size and its distribution.  The outcome of this research and field trial culls on FCS properties illustrated the need for much heavier culling of sika than was traditional. The sika population in 1998 was estimated at 1,100 and subsequent population modelling in 2007 suggests that the 1998 population more probably approached 3,500 sika

Over time, it became recognised that the Group should also pay cognisance to the other deer species (the ubiquitous roe deer and a small nucleus of fallow deer near Peebles) present within the DMG area.  Accordingly, the group became known as the Borders Deer Management Group while under the chairmanship of Maitland Rankin, who succeeded Tony in 2004.

Sir Hew Strachan (Glenhighton) succeeded Maitland in 2011 and is the first chairman from within the DMG area. At that time it was considered desirable to have a Chairman resident within the DMG area to facilitate regular contact with members and to allow day to day events to be noted.

Objectives of the group

  • To promote communication between all parties with an interest in deer within the DMG area.
  • To maintain an awareness of deer related matters on a local, Scottish and international basis.
For more information about the  Borders Deer Management Group please contact John Campbell-Smith, BDMG Secretary, on